Characters: **** (4 stars)
Character Development: **** (4 stars)
Plot: **** (4 stars)
Writing: ***** (5 stars)
Overall: **** (4 stars)
Age range recommendation: 8-14
I’m so excited that Alice Hoffman is putting out another novel for young people! I loved her books when I was a teenager. She captures moments of “everyday magic” like fireflies in jars, and puts them on bookshelves to shed light on the little magical corners of mundane life. Cursed girls, powerful sisters, dangerous misconceptions: these are common, timeless themes in Hoffman’s books. Nightbird is like a little jam jar, stuffed to the brim with twinkling lights, that can be put on the shelf next to her more weighty books or placed on a child’s windowsill to shine alone. (Forgive the fireflies in jars metaphor. Night Bird made me miss the summertime.)
Nightbird is a middle grade book, appropriate for ages 8 and up. It will come out in March, 2015. I read an ARC of the book, so some details may change before publication.
Twig lives on an apple orchard with her beautiful mother, who bakes pink pies to be sold at the general store and diner in town. Sidwell is a small Massachusetts town where everyone knows each other and tries to look out for their neighbors. But Twig’s mother doesn’t want to socialize with the people in town, no matter how friendly they try to be. Ever since she moved back home from New York City, without Twig’s father, they’ve kept mostly to themselves. It’s not because the town will judge them for being a single-parent family; this is a supportive and fairly open-minded place. The problem is that Twig’s family is cursed. A witch used to live in Mourning Dove Cottage, next door to Twig’s house, and she took magical revenge upon one of their ancestors way back during the Revolutionary War. They can’t let anybody find out what they’re hiding. Mourning Dove Cottage has been abandoned for a long time, but now a family of new neighbors has moved in. Fun neighbors, with a girl Twig’s age. Despite her mother’s rule not to hang out with Julia Hall and her glamorous older sister Agate, Twig finds herself pulled into a true friendship for the first time in all her years living in Sidwell.
But there might be a reason for all the secrecy. Their town is supposedly home to a monster. The Sidwell Monster appears on goofy tourist tee shirts and features in local legends, but there’s definitely something truly strange making appearances and stealing from peoples’ yards. Strange graffiti has been showing up on rocks in the forest. Twig knows the woods better than anybody, or so she thinks, but change is stirring among the trees as well as within town. In between her efforts to keep her family’s secret safe and discover who might be creating the mysterious disturbances, Twig and Julia start learning about Agnes Early’s curse, and how it ties their families together. The girls are helped by a mysteriously knowledgeable librarian, a secretive journalist who’s new to town, a perceptive old man, and someone (or something) else, as they do their best to keep Sidwell from caving in to old fears and new threats.
Loving Hoffman’s typical themes and patterns as I do, I kind of knew what to expect when I read Nightbird. Good characters, small miracles, and complex family relationships. It’s a quick book, with a story and setting you can fall into as easily as hopping down from your favorite tree branch. (Thank goodness it wasn’t terribly long, as I had only one night to read it before attending a dinner to celebrate Hoffman’s new work. Thank goodness, too, that the book was completely worth celebrating.) Sidwell was brought to life beautifully; both nature and the town hide sorrow and wonder beneath their surfaces. Parts of it reminded me of my home, even though I’m not very near the Berkshires, just by virtue of that small-town love for a place. Any town with a wise librarian is a town worth reading about, and Miss Larch does not disappoint.
It’s not a perfect place, of course. Twig’s mother is right to worry that people would not know how to react to the family’s difficult situation. But people are generally kind – if overly curious – and little glimpses of extra kindness from a waitress at the Starline Diner, or the kind encouragements from strange old Dr. Shelton, made me wish alongside Twig that her mother would let more people into their secluded life. Unlike some of Hoffman’s books for adults, there’s no overwhelming sense of persecution in Night Bird: more of a nervous tension brought about by bad communication. It’s a nice way to create friction in a Middle Grade novel, and a lot more emotionally resonant than the slightly cheap evil villain just likes being wicked tradition that perseveres in some series.
Twig is a steadfast young narrator. She’ll be an instant kindred spirit to any young readers who have worried that they’ve done something to deserve loneliness. Her family is loving and supportive, but a lack of friends takes its toll on a girl. Who can blame her for breaking the rules and basking in the warmth of the family next door? At the same time, how can we be surprised when she tries to push her new friends away once school starts, worrying that they’ll find out she’s boring and dump her before she has the chance. Luckily, the Halls are good people who can recognize an extraordinary young person when she falls out of a tree. The connections Twig makes with the people she’s barely known for years, getting involved in the community for the first time, are a gratifying benefit to the reading experience.
Nightbird reminded me an awful lot of The Strange And Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender, a novel for older teenagers by Leslye Walton that came out last spring. Well, in fairness, Walton’s book had a theme and style that called Alice Hoffman’s early writing to my mind almost instantly. The similarities are all good though: magical-realist events taking place in towns that seem so real, you’re packing your bags to visit twenty pages in; brave women trying to extract themselves from the weight of their fore-mothers’ pasts; and delectable descriptions of baked goods. I highly recommend that anyone who enjoyed Ava Lavender pick up Nightbird, if ever you’re in a similar mood on a starlit night with only a few hours to spare. Teenaged readers who liked Hoffman’s book should check out Walton, too, even though her debut novel has much more adult issues in it.
Kids in late elementary school, and definitely middle school, will find Nightbird to be transporting and enchanting, with just enough mystery and suspense to keep the plot moving. It’s neither fast paced nor scary, but has lovely emotional depth. Fans of A Snicker Of Magic and Rooftoppers will have a great time in Twig’s town, and history fans will be delighted with the curse’s origin story. I, myself, loved the rumors of witchcraft and the children’s inventive attempts to break the curse. I always like Hoffman’s magic; it flows through the characters and settings so easily, you might get convinced that every town and strange woman has magic at the ready.
And maybe they do.