This is just a tiny review excerpted from my blog post Birthday, Books, Bedtime over at The Bookshelf Pirate. I read The Isle of Youth because it got some good press and I like having new short stories to recommend at the bookshop. Now that it’s the holiday shopping frenzy, I find that collections and anthologies are getting popular as gifts. Short story collections are often a little hit-or-miss for me, but I was intrigued by this unassuming little volume and bought it on a whim. The Isle of Youth is a collection of several short stories by Laura Van Den Berg, all of which tend to focus on displaced women struggling to understand how they relate to their surroundings and to the people in their lives.
Characters: *** 3/5 stars
Writing: *** 3/5 stars
Plots: **1/2 (2 1/2 stars out of 5, because some were great but others bored me.)
About half of the stories really interested me, while others slipped from my memory almost immediately. The title story came at the very end of the collection and it was one of my favorites, probably because it was about a woman’s relationship with her volatile sister and I thought that the characters were entertaining and complex. I find the dynamics between siblings and friends so much more interesting than romantic situations (or, in the case of The Isle of Youth, quiet romantic implosions and disasters). The story “Lessons”, about a band of young bank robbers, was another favorite. In my opinion, there aren’t nearly enough stories about teenaged cousins and siblings on crime sprees! That was another one which gave wacky backgrounds and intense motivations to a cast of characters, despite the short time we get to spend with them. I could have read a whole novel about that family. I also enjoyed the dreary, beer-stained story about a girl who works unhappily with her mother in a cheap magic show.
Though some Van Den Berg’s pieces bled together into an indistinguishable examination of relationships and unspecified discontentment, certain details were vivid and fresh. For example – and this was of particular interest to me though the story itself wasn’t one of my favorites – there was one which mostly took place in Antarctica, but one character had been kidnapped and held hostage in the very towns where I work/have worked. It’s really unnerving to read a fictional account of a girl your age being snatched at knife point mere meters away from where you’re taking your lunch break. So that was cool. One story, which took place in Paris, started out slow but quickly grabbed my interest when acrobats and masquerades came into play. Unfortunately, that particular story suffered from a rushed and inconclusive ending which snatched the magical feeling away in a puff of smoke. There was a lot about marriage, siblings, memory, and ambiguous desires in The Isle Of Youth. Very few of the endings gave us any solid resolutions, but that’s ok because the style was mostly realistic and real life rarely follows any sort of literary structure. Occasionally, characters became too paralyzed by introspection to keep me interested – Van Den Berg’s ladies do like to wallow in their own thoughts – but that might be more a problem of personal preference.
I’d probably give The Isle of Youth 3/5 stars because the individual stories might do better in anthologies than in a collection all by the same author. I got a little tired of their theme after a while and felt a little deflated while I was reading. There’s no denying that Laura Van Den Berg is talented, though, and she clearly put a lot of thought into her characters and their situations. Her writing digs into some deceptively simple parts of life to show how being an adult is confusing for everyone. Reading these stories made me want to try being a little more understanding of the people I encounter every day. The collection is not too long and the stories tend to be of easily digestible lengths. It would be a good gift for someone who doesn’t have too much time to read but who likes to have meaningful conversations at parties, or with themselves.